Sunday, February 3, 2008

Love, the Reptilian Brain, and Selfish Genes

In people there is selfishness, competition, fear, jealousy, and propensities toward violence which can drive people to act viciously in their world. These characteristics are sometimes justified in the name of technological progress. After all, we owe World War II for advances in radar technology, rocket science, and nuclear physics. But this rational may serve humanities undoing in a world where small groups and even individuals wield atomic and biological weapons of genocidal proportions.

People are also capable of reason, foresight, a capacity for love, and a passion for beauty that are undeniably the tools and motives to their survival. It is clear that the former inherent dispositions should be displaced by these. To do this, one must understand what these noble characteristics are and secure the promise they allow one to aspire to.

Reason is the mental practice of interpreting the nature of reality. To know it is to know science, mathematics, history, and philosophy. It begins by generating concepts true by definition. It finishes by producing the most likely theories on the nature of the human predicament. Time tests their credibility. But even with the greatest tests of time, theories are tentative and soi-disant. Reason never proves anything. It only disproves.

Foresight is another human capability that can contribute to humanities survival. This is the ability to make a reasonable guess as to the outcome of events by placing reality’s interpretation into account. By developing an understanding of the most likely truths, one can determine one’s best course of action in life. Reason combined with foresight allows one to make choices that should secure desirable objectives.

While reason and foresight serve as the means behind the wise person’s actions, beauty and love serve as their motive. The splendor of love and all other things comparable in beauty feed the soul. In this, people move beyond existence to live. Reason and foresight can decide the way things will be. But the soul insists that one must not ask what the essence of nature is but of what it ought to be. Should it be a world driven by greed, hatred, and fear or should it be based on reason, foresight, beauty, and love? The affinity of soul would choose the loveliness of the later as primary. The darker motives would find audience only in the poet’s sense of aesthetic. In a roundabout way, they too would find their course to the soul but only in the context of intangible beauty. Beginning and maintaining this suggests the brighter constitutions make up the foundation of good life. They lie essential to humanity’s future success.


It's All About the Love

If altruism does exist, where did it come from? How was it evolved to? To answer this, one has to go back to a time when love may not have existed, a time when reptiles, rather than mammals, ruled the earth.

Life arose on earth three and a half billion years ago. For the first three billion years, the conservation of replicating molecules would reign supreme over the activities of life. Some scientists dub these replicating molecules as “selfish genes” because of their self conserving predisposition. These primitive molecules started interacting with others to compose cellular structure. Multi-cellular organisms arose no less than seven-hundred million years ago. An explosion of life occurred shortly thereafter. By five-hundred billion years ago, life had managed to colonize land. The development of complex nervous systems and brains were soon to follow.


The brain has evolved and grown like a city, where, as the city expands, the inner city remains intact and continues to operate within the confines of the elder intent. The new city or suburbs lie outside the inner city and employ a more neoteric plan. Six hundred million years ago, our ancestors had brains that were limited to controlling automatic systems like heartbeat and breathing. The name of this inner brain is the neural chassis. The neural chassis still operates in the human brain today. It still controls essentially the same activities it has always directed. But much more exists in the human brain than merely this system. About the age of the reptiles a new part of the brain evolved outside the neural chassis. This part is called the reptilian complex or R-complex. The behavior and function of this brain region is much more advanced than the neural chassis. It is from this part of the brain that selfish motivation arises. Selfishness, before the R-complex evolved, had presence only in the mimicry of the “selfish” gene. It is suggested, that the selfish gene’s agenda reaches extra genetic potential in the reptilian brain. The extra genetic potential for selfishness is suggested to be reflected in the lives of dinosaurs. But selfish motivation wasn’t enough. A new creature appeared on the circuit. Nature found out that sometimes it was advantageous for “selfish” genes to cooperate. To raise young required an organism to be sensitive to the needs of others. To live and hunt in packs required collaboration. With this, a new layer of the brain evolved over the other two. Mammals came into being. The layer outside the R-complex is called the limbic system. This is the home of higher brain functions like altruism. Birds and mammals have well developed limbic systems.

It’s important to note that genes don’t think. They haven’t rationalized that altruism will contribute to their conservation. “Selfish” genes don’t allow altruism to be cooperative. That would imply reason. It is simply by happenstance that altruism serves the gene. While altruism exists because of the gene, it does not exist by the gene’s dictate beyond the automatic biochemistry of the design.

Altruism, like selfishness, is a program. It’s a child program when compared to the older selfish program. In this child program lays the feel good associated with being altruistic. This program was not rationalized. It simply came into being. It exists only in the context that it is unselfish. Pure altruism is the nature of the program. The program knows of no selfish gene. Selfish motivation played itself out. A new program was needed for the gene to continue. Altruism was born. While we can rationalize this evolution as selfishly motivated, neither the program nor the gene can. Only reason and the R-complex see the selfishness. That’s like asking an agrarian if they think city life is backward. Reason can justify altruism only in terms of self preservation.

The merits, importance, and even reality of altruism is often debated. Some go so far as to assert that everything is selfishly motivated. This is a religion of selfishness. For a gene to be selfish, it would have to have an R-complex. It does not. In fact, it is just as easy to imagine a gene altruistic as it is to imagine it selfish. Perhaps a gene is acting selfishly in order to be altruistic. It would be like denying a street bum a handout so he is forced to get a job and better his as well as everyone else’s lives. But, to believe the gene altruistic is just as unrealistic as to call it selfish. Altruism and selfishness are simply not the stuff genes are made of. To assert life as fundamentally selfish or altruistic is an irrational religious assertion.

Evolutionary history serves as proof to the merits of altruism. In the age of dinosaurs, the reptile had an R-complex and a primitive limbic system. At the same time, there were smaller, weak, rodent like creatures who had a more developed limbic system as well as the R-complex. Sixty-five million years ago, an adversity occurred that caused mass extinction. Most of the reptiles went extinct. The child rearing rodents took over the world. The case can be put to rest. Altruism not only exists, it is essential to humanity’s survival. People should engage it and should never deny it.

No comments: